Two Away bags turned into four. And somehow my entire family has opinions.
Affiliate disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. That means I may earn a small commission if you choose to purchase through them, at no extra cost to you. I only share products we personally use, love and travel with. Every recommendation here is based on our actual experience.
If you've followed me for a while, you already know that carry-on-only travel is basically part of my personality at this point.
I travel with the standard Away Carry-On.
Brandon travels with the Away Bigger Carry-On, because he wanted a little more room and, let's be honest, the Alabama version probably didn't hurt. 😂
Then my parents bought Away bags too.
My dad chose the same standard Carry-On I use. My mom chose the Bigger Carry-On.
So what started as a review of two suitcases has accidentally turned into a four-person family case study.
And here's the interesting part:
We're all happy with the size we chose.
That's why I don't think there's one "best" Away Carry-On.
There's a best one for the way you actually travel.
And after airports, cruises, Europe, tiny elevators, cobblestone streets and more overhead bins than I can count, I definitely have opinions.
The Lazy Girl Quick Answer
Don't feel like reading an entire article about luggage? I completely understand.
Here's our extremely scientific family luggage study:
Me: Away Carry-On
I pack light, travel frequently and don't want more suitcase just because I can have it.
My dad: Away Carry-On
He chose the same smaller size and is very happy with it.
Brandon: Away Bigger Carry-On
He likes having more breathing room. And Roll Tide. 🏈
My mom: Away Bigger Carry-On
She likes the extra space and is perfectly happy pulling it herself through the airport.
Four travelers. Two sizes. Nobody wants to trade.
And then there's my sonTanner.
I actually offered to buy him an Away because he loves steering mine through the airport. He declined. For now, he's perfectly happy traveling with his Samsonite backpack.
Honestly? I respect it.
I will absolutely invest in good luggage for him before he heads out traveling on his own, but right now he doesn't need it.
Which is actually a pretty good summary of my entire Lazy Girl approach:
Buy what makes the way you travel easier. Not what somebody tells you you're supposed to own.
Why I Still Choose the Smaller Away Carry-On
Here's my bias right up front:
I have never wished I bought the Bigger Carry-On.
Not once.
I don't want to pack more simply because my suitcase gives me permission to pack more.
My standard Carry-On gives me enough room for the way I travel, and its smaller footprint is one of the things I like most about it.
I've taken it on domestic trips, cruises and European trips. I know how to pack it. I know what fits. I don't spend the night before a trip contemplating whether I really need six more outfits.
Spoiler: I don't.
For a typical trip, I can comfortably fit around 5–7 outfits, depending on what I'm bringing.
And I pair it with a personal item, usually my Away Featherlight Overnight or Samsonite Motherlode Junior.
That combination works for me over and over again.
Could I squeeze more into a Bigger Carry-On?
Of course.
But I don't want to.
That's the important difference.
Why Brandon Chose the Bigger Carry-On
My husband Brandon is not interested in participating in my suitcase minimalism Olympics.
And that's okay. 😂
His Bigger Carry-On gives him a little extra breathing room for bulkier shoes, layers and another outfit or two.
For the way he packs, that extra room is useful rather than wasted.
And yes, his happens to be an Alabama version.
If you're wondering whether a grown man's college football allegiance can influence luggage selection, apparently the answer is yes.
The funny thing is that his choice doesn't make me question mine at all.
We can pack for the exact same vacation and each be perfectly happy rolling a different-size suitcase out the door.
That's really what convinced me that this isn't a "better bag" question.
It's a better bag for you question.
And Then My Parents Bought Them
This is the part of the review I didn't have when I originally wrote it.
My parents eventually bought Away bags too.
Dad went with my standard Carry-On.
Mom went Bigger.
And everybody is happy.
But there was an unexpected benefit for my parents that had nothing to do with packing capacity.
My dad had gotten into the habit of dealing with both his luggage and my mom's luggage in airports.
You know how that happens. One person becomes the unofficial family baggage department and suddenly they're trying to navigate an airport while controlling multiple suitcases.
Now?
Mom happily pulls her own bag.
Dad has his.
Mom has hers.
Everybody is responsible for their own wheels.
Everybody is happier.
Honestly, that might be one of my favorite endorsements of this luggage. If your suitcase is easy enough to handle that nobody has to appoint a designated luggage wrangler, I'm calling that a win.
What We Can Actually Fit
My Carry-On
I generally fit about 5–7 outfits, depending on the trip and how bulky everything is.
But the suitcase isn't really my secret.
My packing system is.
I use packing cubes. I bring pieces that work together. I don't pack a second vacation wardrobe for an imaginary version of myself who may suddenly require four additional outfits.
I've been doing carry-on-only travel long enough that I've learned what I actually use.
Shop My Carry-On Only Travel Essentials
These are the bags, packing helpers, and travel essentials I actually use to make carry-on-only travel work trip after trip.
This section contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission if you shop through my links, at no additional cost to you. I only share products I actually use, love, or recommend.
Brandon's Bigger Carry-On
Brandon gets more wiggle room.
He can fit roughly 6–9 outfits, depending on what he's packing, and the additional room works particularly well when he's bringing heavier shoes or bulkier clothing.
He isn't trying to pack like me.
And he shouldn't.
That's the point.
Okay Julie, Just Tell Me Which One to Buy
Get the Away Carry-On if…
You want the smaller option and you're comfortable being intentional about what you pack.
That's me.
That's Dad.
I'd also lean toward this size if you're someone who frequently moves through tighter spaces and simply doesn't want more suitcase than you actually need.
Get the Bigger Carry-On if…
You know you're going to use the extra room.
Maybe you bring bulkier clothing.
Maybe you want an extra pair of shoes.
Maybe the idea of narrowing your vacation wardrobe down to five outfits makes you irrationally angry.
That's Brandon.
That's Mom.
They're happy.
And neither one is secretly trying to trade bags with me or Dad.
The Lazy Girl Verdict
If my Carry-On disappeared tomorrow and I had to replace it, I'd buy the same size again.
No hesitation.
I have never been standing in an airport thinking:
You know what would really improve this situation? More suitcase.
Want More Lazy Girl Travel?
Browse my Lazy Girl Series for the packing guides, cruise strategies, travel gear and shortcuts I use to make travel easier without overcomplicating it.
And if you want to see exactly what travels with me, check out my Lazy Girl Carry-On Only Travel Essentials.
About Julie
Hi, I'm Julie Davis, the traveler behind No Point Left Behind. I've spent more than 20 years figuring out how to make points, miles and smart travel strategies work in real life.
Around here, I'm much more interested in showing you what I actually do than giving you another list of travel rules you're supposedly required to follow.
I share the trips I take, the products I use, the mistakes I've made and the strategies that have actually made travel easier for me and my family.
That's what Lazy Girl Approved means around here: less overthinking, smarter choices and more time enjoying the trip.