Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. If you book or purchase through one of my links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As always, I only share cruises, hotels, products, and travel strategies based on my own experiences.
Let me start with something important:
I love Virgin Voyages.
Seriously. Virgin is totally my vibe.
I sailed with Virgin five times in about two years, and I wouldn't have kept going back if I wasn't having a good time. I love the adults-only atmosphere, the food, the restaurants, and the fact that Virgin does cruising a little differently.
If you're considering your first sailing, I still think there is a lot to love.
→ Read My Virgin Voyages Guide for First-Time Cruisers
So why haven't I booked another Virgin cruise lately?
Honestly, Virgin didn't really do anything wrong.
I may have simply sailed them too much, too fast.
Five Virgin Cruises in Two Years Might Have Been a Lot 😂
Here's the thing about the way I cruise: I cruise a lot.
And most of my cruises are in the Caribbean.
That means that even though I tried different Virgin ships and different sailings, somewhere around cruise four or five I started getting this weird feeling:
Haven't I already taken this vacation?
Not the exact itinerary. Not the exact ship.
The experience.
The restaurants felt familiar. The overall vibe felt familiar. The Caribbean itineraries felt familiar.
All of those things were still good. They just weren't giving me that same ooh, what's next? feeling anymore.
And I think that's an important distinction.
I didn't get off a Virgin ship one day and think, Well, I'm never doing THAT again.
It was more like:
Okay. I think I need to miss you for a while.
That's Also One of Virgin's Strengths
Here's where this gets complicated.
Part of what started feeling familiar after five cruises is exactly what can make Virgin so easy to recommend to someone taking a first or second sailing.
I knew there were restaurants I loved.
→ Read My Virgin Voyages Restaurant Guide
I knew how dining worked.
I knew what I wanted to book.
I knew which parts of the ship I enjoyed.
I knew the little Virgin quirks that can feel confusing when you first sail with them.
→ Read My Virgin Voyages Tips for First-Time Cruisers
There is something really nice about stepping onboard and knowing how everything works.
But because I travel so frequently, eventually I realized I was craving something new.
Virgin Is Totally My Vibe, So What Happened?
This is probably the funniest part of this entire story.
On paper, Virgin might be more "me."
Adults only? Yes.
Really good food? Absolutely.
A cruise line that doesn't feel overly traditional? I'm in.
There is a reason I went back five times.
But there's another part of how I travel that matters just as much:
I need the numbers to work.
I cruise as frequently as I do because I combine points, miles, credit card perks, hotel certificates, casino offers, and whatever other travel tools make sense for a particular trip.
I didn't do especially well with casino offers on Virgin.
And casino offers are a big part of how I'm able to cruise as often as I do.
Then I started sailing Princess more.
And Princess started fitting my travel life really well.
And Then Princess Happened
I didn't switch to Princess because I suddenly decided Virgin wasn't good.
Princess just became a better fit for me trip after trip.
The offers worked better for the way I travel. I enjoyed the ships. I liked having different options. And the more I sailed Princess, the more it made sense to keep going back.
→ Explore My Princess Cruises Guide
That's really what changed.
Virgin fit my personality. Princess started fitting my travel life.
And when you're cruising as frequently as I do, that difference matters.
I'm not choosing between two cruise lines for one big vacation every year. I'm constantly looking at what trips are available, what they're going to cost me, what offers I have, and where I actually want to go next.
Princess kept winning that decision.
→ Read How I Book My Casino Cruise Deals
The Caribbean Probably Has Something to Do With It Too
I want to be fair to Virgin here because this may have turned out very differently if I'd been sailing all over the world with them.
I primarily cruise the Caribbean.
After five Virgin sailings in two years, even switching ships didn't necessarily make the trip feel completely different to me.
There was a point when I realized I didn't need another version of a vacation I'd just taken.
I wanted something new.
That's not necessarily an indictment of Virgin. If anything, it might be an indictment of me booking the same style of vacation five times in two years. 😂
Give me a completely different Virgin itinerary someday and this conversation might change very quickly.
What I Still Think Virgin Does Really Well
Taking a break hasn't erased the things I loved.
The food is still a huge one for me.
Virgin's approach to dining was one of the things that originally made the cruise line stand out.
→ See My Virgin Voyages Restaurant Reviews & Dining Guide
And I still appreciate that Virgin feels different.
It doesn't feel like someone took a traditional cruise ship and simply changed the colors.
There are things about Virgin that are unmistakably Virgin.
I also enjoyed the perks I received once I had them.
→ Read My Virgin Voyages Deep Blue Extras Guide
None of those things suddenly stopped being good because I started sailing Princess more.
What I Actually Pack for Virgin Voyages
After five Virgin Voyages sailings, these are the things that have actually earned a spot in my suitcase. No giant packing list, just the outfits, essentials and little favorites I'd bring again.
Affiliate disclosure: This collection contains affiliate links. I may earn a commission if you purchase or book through my links, at no additional cost to you. I only share things I actually use, love or would personally recommend.
Would I Still Recommend Virgin Voyages?
Yes, especially if you haven't sailed them five times in two years. 😂
If Virgin's style appeals to you, I wouldn't let the fact that I'm currently taking a break discourage you.
My experience is coming from the perspective of someone who cruises very frequently and repeated the same general type of Virgin vacation several times in a pretty condensed period.
Your first Virgin cruise isn't going to feel like my fifth.
In fact, some of what eventually became familiar to me may be exactly what makes your first sailing so much fun.
That's why I still keep my Virgin guides updated and available.
→ Start Here: My Virgin Voyages Guides
Want to see if Virgin feels like your kind of cruise?
Browse current Virgin Voyages sailings and see which itineraries catch your eye.
Affiliate link: I may earn a commission if you book through my link, at no additional cost to you.
Would I Sail Virgin Voyages Again?
Absolutely.
This isn't a breakup.
It's a break. 😂
I'd especially be tempted by an itinerary that felt genuinely different from the Caribbean trips I've already done.
And honestly, enough time away may be all I need.
There is something to be said for not overdoing something you really enjoy.
Maybe the next time I walk onto a Virgin ship, instead of thinking I know exactly how this vacation goes, I'll think:
Ohhhh. I missed this.
And that's exactly how I want it to feel.
Final Thoughts
I don't think every cruise line has to be either the best or never again.
Travel isn't that simple.
Virgin Voyages can still be completely my vibe while Princess is currently a better fit for the way I cruise.
I can love Virgin's food, atmosphere, and approach to cruising while admitting that five sailings in two years was probably enough for me for a while.
And I can choose Princess more often because the offers and overall experience are working better for this season of my travel life.
That doesn't make one cruise line universally better than the other.
It just means I've learned something after cruising this much:
The best cruise line isn't always the one you love most on paper. Sometimes it's the one that fits the trip you want to take right now.
About Julie
Julie Davis is the creator of No Point Left Behind, where she shares her real experiences using points, miles, travel perks, and cruise offers to travel more often without pretending there is one "right" way to do it. She cruises frequently and writes about the ships, hotels, deals, and strategies she actually uses.